CYBER FORENSICS · PRIVACY & AI · LEGAL TECHNOLOGY · MANAGED ITCall us 24/7: (289) 582-9930
What to do

What to do if personal information was emailed to the wrong person

Misdirected email is one of the most common ways personal information ends up where it shouldn't. Most cases are manageable, but they still need to be assessed and recorded.

3 min readCyber Forensics

Reviewed by the ITRS security team · Last updated

Recall: what it can and can't do

Outlook's message recall only works in limited circumstances: generally when the recipient is in the same Microsoft 365 organization and hasn't opened the message yet. Recall to an external address, or to someone who has already read it, won't work, and may draw attention to the message. Try it if the recipient is internal, but don't rely on it.

If you use Microsoft Purview Message Encryption or sensitivity labels with access controls, an admin may be able to revoke access to an encrypted message. That's worth checking quickly when it applies.

Contact the recipient for deletion confirmation

  1. Reach the recipient promptly

    Call if you have a number; otherwise send a short, polite email.

  2. Ask them not to open, forward or keep it

    If already opened, ask them to delete it, empty their deleted items, and delete any downloaded attachments.

  3. Ask for written confirmation

    A one-line email confirming deletion and that the information wasn't shared is valuable evidence for your assessment.

  4. Note their response

    Who they are, whether they're another business or an individual, how they responded and when.

Assess real risk of significant harm

Under PIPEDA, an organization must report a breach of security safeguards to the Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada and notify the affected individuals if it is reasonable to believe the breach creates a real risk of significant harm (RROSH). The two main factors are how sensitive the information is (for example, health, financial, government ID numbers) and the probability it has been, is being or will be misused. The OPC publishes an online RROSH assessment tool.

A misdirected email to a known professional who confirms deletion is often low risk. The same file sent to an unknown personal address, or to a mailing list, is not. Write down your reasoning either way.

FactorLower riskHigher risk
Information
Names and business contact details
SIN, health, financial, ID images, passwords
Recipient
Known, trusted organization; confirmed deletion
Unknown individual; no response; forwarded
Volume
One person's limited details
Many people, or a whole spreadsheet
Protection
Encrypted attachment, key not sent
Unprotected attachment or body text

Record it even if you don't report

The Breach of Security Safeguards Regulations require organizations to keep a record of every breach of security safeguards for 24 months after determining it occurred, whether or not it met the reporting threshold. The record should contain enough to show the OPC how you assessed it. A short entry is enough for low-risk misdirected email: what was sent, to whom, when, the recipient's response and your conclusion.

Notify where required

If you conclude there's a real risk of significant harm, the report to the OPC and notice to individuals must be given as soon as feasible. The notice to individuals should describe what happened, what information was involved, what you've done, and what they can do to protect themselves.

Other laws may apply. Health information custodians in Ontario have notification duties under PHIPA and must report certain breaches to the Information and Privacy Commissioner of Ontario as well as file annual breach statistics. Quebec, Alberta and BC have their own regimes, and public bodies follow separate legislation.

Reduce repeats: autocomplete and DLP

  • Clear stale entries from Outlook's autocomplete list for staff who handle sensitive data.
  • Turn on external-recipient warnings (MailTips) so senders see when a message leaves the organization.
  • Use Microsoft Purview data loss prevention policies to warn or block when sensitive information types, such as SIN or credit card numbers, are sent externally.
  • Send sensitive documents through secure sharing links that can be revoked, not attachments.
  • Consider a short send delay rule so people can catch mistakes.
Keep reading

Related reading.

  • PageUnder attack? Start hereIf something is wrong right now, this page tells you what to do in the next few minutes, what to avoid, and which step-by-step guide fits what you are seeing.
  • ArticleReal risk of significant harm: how the assessment worksWhether a Canadian privacy breach must be reported usually turns on one judgment: does it create a real risk of significant harm? The legal test is short.
  • ArticlePIPEDA breach reporting and record-keepingPIPEDA has three linked breach duties: report serious breaches to the Privacy Commissioner, notify the people affected, and keep a record of every breach, even the small…
  • GuideSecure file sharing with clientsTax returns, medical notes, settlement drafts and payroll files still travel as email attachments every day. Most of the time nothing goes wrong.
Incident line · 24 hours, 7 days

Under attack right now?

Call before you reset passwords, wipe a laptop or pay anyone. A responder will help you contain the incident without destroying the evidence you will need later.